Revealing hidden assumptions in estimation

Posted by Jamis on November 19, 2005 @ 08:30 AM

37signals recently released an update to Backpack that allows each page to have multiple to-do lists, rather than just one. Many, many people seemed to think this should have been a trivial thing to implement, so rather than leave them with that impression, I wrote up a bit about the reality of the situation on Signal vs. Noise.

Posted in Essays and Rants

Comments

Have something to add? Click here to leave a comment.

20 Nov 2005

1. Maik said...

Thank you for being open about the situation and the problems involved. Rather than repeating the "YOU DON'T NEED THAT FEATURE" crap! And there is a lot of that in the forum. I do admit that many many features requested are unnecessary, ugly and probably dangerous, but somtetimes there are some excellent Ideas and those should be at least recognized as such, even though the implementation may be temporarily challenging. Honesty pays off! You are doing a great job.

2. jason said...

nice writeup, jamis. Personally, when i hear my brain prepare a sentence with the words "just" or "only" in them, i force myself to stop and re-evaluate what i am about to say. The problem of estimation grows exponentially as your application increases in size, as your development group experiences turnover, etc. There are times when i know 100% that a given thing will "just be a conf file change," but those times are few and far between.